Friday, January 08, 2010

One Year Ago Today...

...I posted this:

"...today some sad protestors at the ASB Tennis Classic in Auckland - protesting professional tennis player Israeli Shahar Peer's involvement - Global Peace and Justice aka John Minto, parading the so-called "developing international consensus" for a sport boycott - which right now doesn't exist so GPJ are on a limb with this one - local influence being leveraged by international tragedy through unilateral action not yet justified by international consensus - there may be a place for boycotts through sport but you do it with the accountability of international consensus when the protection of one group's rights involves the infringement of another person's rights - the sacrifice of one person's rights ostensibly for the rights of others."

6 comments:

Rhett said...

This Minto guy strikes me as the used-car salesman of protesting.

Anonymous said...

Your blog keeps getting better and better! Your older articles are not as good as newer ones you have a lot more creativity and originality now keep it up!

Frank said...

The protest is just worthless show-boating and says nothing... and heck, I'm hugely sympathetic to the plight of the Palestinians.

Protesting against a sports star who served in the Israeli military as everyone legally has to at a certain age doesn't help the Palestinians, it just serves the conscience of the protesters who are achieving nothing except some media coverage that offers no education on the issue.

BJ said...

Rhett - an apt image - selling the same car!

Anonymous - I think my old posts are better than my new ones - did you have any examples in mind?

Frank - part of the problem with protest in our society is that it is a legitimate form of expression (within the boundaries of nuisance) - to me that actually marginalises the effectiveness of some protest - "you have the right to your point of view, now we can ignore it." All that this has done in terms of education has created a negative association between the Palestinian side of the conflict and the divisive Mr Minto.

Frank said...

ll that this has done in terms of education has created a negative association between the Palestinian side of the conflict and the divisive Mr Minto.

Sad but too true. I wish people would think this stuff through rather than just trying to grab a headline.

If it was an Israeli ambassador/politician or army general then I'd say go for it. That would frame the issue a whole lot better.

BJ said...

But what was really cool was that she did pretty well in the tournament!