Wednesday, July 15, 2009

Absent for the AB's

So I will miss this weekend's test match at Eden Park - oh that I could be there. The team has a predicatable look about it, but some points of interest, mostly in the reserves:

  • Donald gets the nod at 1st V - I think this was likely given the way he was being talked up in the media - plus he gets his chance as the incumbent with a full strength side;
  • Cowan keeps Leonard out for the moment;
  • Tialata retains his role, but what is interesting is that Afoa doesn't even make the bench. Franks had a very good debut off the bench and perhaps he is seen as the guy for this role longer term;
  • Sivivatu replaces cousin Joe, but interestingly Corey Jane is starting - you get the sense that Toeva would have started at wing had he been fit, leaving Jane on the bench - this is a ploy for the Australian kicking game - the back 3 all have experience at full back;
  • Eaton is the comeback kid (predicted on this blog) covering lock and I guess the loosies;
  • However the loosie mix (including reserves) has an unbalanced feel for me - who will cover McCaw? Obviously Rodney will, a ploy that has not worked before. Read is being rewarded for being the most compelling of the new loose forwards but overall the balance is not assisted;

This is a pretty experienced forward pack with a ton of experience and graft with an injection of newer blood (in Kaino and Ross). It is easily the best we can do (with the exception of Tialata who needs a big one). The backline restores some combinations but the yawning hole remains at 1st V. I would have picked McAlister, simply because I think he shades Donald in all departments - kicking, passing, running and tackling - and has the greater vision. But neither of them are Dan Carter. And that sadly may be the difference.

It will be 3.30am here when the game is on. I don't think I can get it live - I have found a provider who plays it 9 hours later, but I've yet to work out how I can access that! A work in progress!

4 comments:

Rhett said...

Finally a post on something worthwhile! ;-)

Good team for me... biggest interest was that Jane makes the side. And, since when can Sivivatu kick?

As for Donald, well, neither him nor McAlister inspires. I would have gone with McAlister too, but maybe they are looking for a "steadier" hand rather than a more dynamic one. We shall see!

BJ said...

I think Sivavatu has played a bit of fullback for the Chiefs and is seen as a little more rounded in the kicking department than his cuzzy. Its all relative mind you!

Donald comes across to me as a bit frenetic and all over the place, like he's trying to be Dan Carter but without the skills or judgment! All those stupid quick droppies and so forth. I doubt I'll get to see it, but will watch your blog keenly for your considered opinion!

BJ said...

Come quickly Lord...

http://www.nzherald.co.nz/rugby/news/article.cfm?c_id=80&objectid=10584862

Rhett said...

The rupture followed by the extened time of tribulation.